The View From Traverse City

Balancing development and growth with maintaining small-town charm. COVID. Infrastructure. The environment. Taxes. Parking.

Whether you are 1st Selectwoman of Westport or mayor of Traverse City, Michigan, every suburban political leader deals every day with issues like those, large and small.

Ask Jim Carruthers. The 1982 Staples High School graduate just retired as mayor of the Great Lakes resort town. His 3 terms followed service on the City Commission.

Jim Carruthers, in the 1979 Coleytown Junior High School yearbook …

Carruthers loves Traverse City. His grandparents bought a summer home there in the 1930s. He moved to Westport from Cincinnati with his parents, and entered Coleytown Junior High.

Friends often wondered why he spent his summers in Michigan. They didn’t realize how beautiful the lakes were, how pure the air.

Now, he says, they understand.

Carruthers enjoyed growing up in Westport. He rode his bike to the beach, took the Minnybus and Maxytaxy all over town, and appreciated that New York City was a train ride away.

After graduating from Staples High School in 1982 and the University of Connecticut 4 years later, he worked as a yacht broker in Marblehead, Massachusetts.

But in 1989, when his blind grandmother needed help at the summer cottage, Carruthers volunteered.

He did not plan to stay. But he’s been there ever since.

… and today.

He got involved in conservation and environmental issues. When his best friend was diagnosed with HIV, he ran an AIDS services program for 10 years.

Carruthers was active too in Planned Parenthood. He’s still on the development committee.

“I’m a gay man. But women’s rights is my biggest cause,” he says.  “Until women are treated equally, no one will be.”

His grandfather was mayor of Glendale, a Cincinnati suburb, for 43 years. Carruthers spent 8 years on the Traverse City Parks & Recreation Commission, before his election to the city commission in 2007.

Meanwhile, he was advocating for many causes: installation of what would be Michigan’s first utility-scale wind turbine; opposition to construction of a 4-story parking structure; inclusion of sexual orientation in the city’s anti-discrimination policies.

It was all part of making his community a better place to live. Besides being the “Cherry Capital of the World,” Traverse City had evolved from a summer resort for Midwesterners to a tourist mecca that draws visitors from all over.

There’s skiing, snowmobiling, hunting, and of course water and dunes. Carruthers rows 5 miles a day, and sails too.

The Traverse City waterfront.

As mayor — a non-partisan post — Carruthers understood the role tourism plays in Traverse City. He dedicated himself to water quality issues, including trying to shut an 80-year-old pipeline that, he says, “will eventually break and spill oil.”

His town beat its goal to power all municipal operations with clean power. They hope to switch entirely to renewables by 2040.

One of the perks of being mayor: taking a selfie with the President of the United States, when he visits your town.

Carruthers kept his focus on human rights issues too. But when COVID drew an influx of people to their second homes — and brought others, seeking to buy — Traverse City grappled with issues of real estate and growth.

Meanwhile, exploding real estate prices made it increasingly difficult for town employees, teachers, and retail and other workers to live nearby.

Sound familiar?

“I’m not anti-growth,” the former mayor says. “But we’re a town of 15,000. We want to maintain our small-town charm. That’s who we are.”

Carruthers calls Traverse City “a blue town in a red county.” The Michigan Militia is based not far away. Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh trained with them. They were accused in a plot to kidnap Governor Gretchen Whitmer — a friend of Carruthers’.

Jim Carruthers and Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer.

He too received death threat.

“Politics is hard,” Carruthers says. “I was just trying to fix walking trails, and get clean water. But because I supported masking and vaccines — trying to help my community stay safe — I was a target.”

Last year — citing a desire to spend more time with his aging parents, his husband and his own health — he decided not to run for a 3rd term.

Carruthers is still deeply involved in Traverse City. He still works with Planned Parenthood; he’s on the board of Dann’s House, a non-profit supportive housing agency for people with alcoholism (“we have a homeless problem, just like every place”), and as president of Friends of the Senior Center, he’s working to get a new building.

The former mayor has been approached to run for state representative. So far, he’s declined.

“I like the local level better,” Carruthers says. “That’s where you really see the results of what you get done.”

(Hat tip: Dan Donovan)

(“06880” is truly “Where Westport meets the world.” Readers anywhere can support this non-profit blog; please click here for details.)

Jim Carruthers with a famous Michigander, Michael, Moore.

9 responses to “The View From Traverse City

  1. Great story Dan. What a tremendous devoted community driven man.

  2. Wow! how much better would Westport be had Jim stayed here and given us the energy and devotion he has given Traverse City.

  3. Terrific story! Another wonderful example of your tagline. By the way, that’s an amazing run Jim’s grandfather had as mayor of that Ohio suburb.

  4. Jim’s story caused me to wonder how many people who grew up in Westport and moved to other places and became mayors of their new towns. As much as I Ioved Westport, I felt the need to move in 1981 and eventually became the mayor (2002-04 and again 2012-14) of a very small town in Florida, Melbourne Village, 35 miles south of Kennedy Space Center.

    • Carl Addison Swanson, '66

      Tim Honey, Staples Class of ’64, was city manager in Denver during the Ramsey murder. Took some serious heat.

  5. John D McCarthy

    Jim, great to see you at the 40th reunion.

  6. After 30 years in Westport I was thrilled to move to the Traverse City area 4 years ago, where I have summered since 1960. Jim is a neighbor, local statesman, and dedicated progressive. Westport produced a gem in Jim. If you want pine-scented air, Carribean-blue crystal clear water, and people generous with a wave or smile – visit us UpNorth!

  7. Thank you Dan for the kind review of my life and for taking the time to talk with me about it. Life is good and I was lucky to grow up in Westport and then move back closer to my family roots. It was not always easy but it was great to get back after all these years and connect with old friends. Not sure what’s next for me but I’ve enjoyed life thus far! Be well my friend and thank you all for the positive comments!

  8. Well deserved Jim!

Leave a Reply