You Can Check Out Any Time You Like…

Avid “06880” reader Bill Scheffler liked last year’s list of long-gone, much-loved (or, conversely, quickly forgotten) Westport restaurants.

He responded with a list of his own:  old local hotels.

It was a great, blog-worthy idea.  I was going to run it — honest, I was — but I guess 21st-century life intruded.

Back in the day -- and in another location -- this was the original Westport Inn.

I found Bill’s email the other day.  Because bygone buildings have no sell-by date, his list is as fresh as ever.

Bill begins by noting our most recent hotel closing — the Inn at National Hall — along with the Westport Inn’s predecessor, the New Englander.

That’s too easy.  Here are others.  Some may be dimly recalled by old-time Westporters; others may be lost in the shrouds of time to all.  In alphabetical order, they are:

Beachside Inn: Described by Bill as “a large, impressive oceanfront Victorian building in Green’s Farms.”

Compo Inn: Edward Nash bought the old Christ Church on what was then West Church Street (now Ludlow Road), up the hill from Post Road West — now condos — and turned it into a summer hotel.  He added a restaurant (Tony’s), which became a popular hangout.

Golden Door: One of several motels located on the Westport-Norwalk stretch of the Post Road.  A few remain (in Norwalk), though from the looks of them I’m guessing you pay by the hour, not the day.

Hawthorne Inn: Located at the southeast corner of the Post Road and Compo Road South (current site of Patriot Bank).

Jassil’s Penguin Hotel and Shorehouse: Known familiarly as The Penguin, even after it became the Miramar and then the Sound View Hotel.  An Art Deco landmark on Hillspoint Road — just beyond the I-95 and railroad bridges — it was believed (by my young friends and I, long after its heyday) — to be a bawdy place that, remarkably, rhymed with “shorehouse.”

Mathewson’s Tourist Cabins: A tourist guide listed it as “near the Greyhound Terminal and the Beaches.”  Well, the bus depot was in the building where (most recently) the Peppermill stood.  And “the beaches” haven’t moved.  So I’m not exactly sure where one would have found Mathewson’s Tourist Cabins.

Open Door Inn: Later known as the General Putnam Inn, this was razed to make way for the current police station.

Pine Knoll: Perhaps more of a boardinghouse than a hotel, this old Victorian mansion stood in what is now Playhouse Square (behind the old Derma Clinic).  It was owned by the Kemper family, who also owned the tannery that became the adjacent Westport Country Playhouse.

Westport Inn (the original):  A guidebook called this, somewhat ungrammatically, “AAA’s only accredited inn at Westport, Conn. Center of Art Colony.”  It’s still standing — the white building at the rear of Colonial Green.  But it’s been moved twice from its original location, on the southeast corner of the Post Road and Imperial Avenue.  The 1st move was to the front of Colonial Green, where Webster Bank now sits.

Thanks, Bill, for the trip down Memory Lane.  Which may one of the few places in Westport to never house a hotel.

5 responses to “You Can Check Out Any Time You Like…

  1. Compo Inn also had a very shady reputation. It was opposite the Ludlow Condos on Ludlow road. There were “seedy looking” appts where the Condo unit stands now.

  2. Larry Perlstein

    What about the Westporter Motel? It used to be on the Post Road on the Norwalk/Westport line behind a diner which isn’t there anymore either. My family stayed there when we moved to Westport in 1970. It was a dump back then.

  3. Dan: Stella Mathewson lived on South Maple Avenue (between George and Highgate Streets) and her Mathewson’s Cabins were on East State Street n/k/a Post Road East until they were replaced by the New Englander Hotel. They were knocked down in the 1950s to make way for the New Englander. No historic Commission in those days. They looked like those cabins you can still see up near Lake George and in Vt. and New Hampshire. Some people salvaged some of the cabins and used them as work shops and tool sheds–saw one a few years ago at a home near Old Road.

  4. Innocent Bystander

    I assume the “Three Bears Inn” was once a place of lodging????