Gaetano’s is one of Westport’s favorite delis. Lee Shufro is a fan. He writes:
While you can chase immortality by putting your name on a building, there is no finer honor than to have a sandwich named after you.
The “sandwich” itself was named for John Montagu, the 12th Earl of Sandwich. The Reuben (pastrami or corned beef with sauerkraut on rye) was supposedly named after Arnold Reuben, owner of NYC’s Reuben’s Deli.
While Westport has many great sandwich purveyors, my favorite is Gaetano’s, off Post Road opposite Stop & Shop.
What makes it a great deli? In my opinion you not only need the finest ingredients, but also some personality.
As important as the homemade mozzarella and aged salami are, is a high degree of banter. “Hey!” “Yo!” Gaetano’s has it all in spades.
Which brings us to my problem. I have followed a plant-based (aka vegan) diet for over 20 years. It prohibits me from eating meat or cheese — their entire menu.
The Food Network used this photo to illustrate Gaetano’s menu. It was not on Lee Shufro’s plate, however.
When I gaze upon Gaetano’s sandwich board, I see sandwiches a carnivore would love — but not one for vegan/vegetarians.
Over the years I ordered bespoke sandwiches, with various veggies.
Finally, after hundreds of experiments, I had hit upon the optimum non-dairy, non-meat concoction. I took a picture of it, to reference it on my next order.
My visits followed a routine. Whenever I got to the front of the line I was greeted with a hearty “How ya doin’?” I always replied, “The King is good.”
I don’t know what goes on in my head, but that was the routine every time I ordered.
To make it easy, I just showed the picture of my veggie sandwich. Affter a while, I began calling my sandwich “The King of Westport.”
Recently I said, “I think there may be other people who want this type of sandwich.”
They said, “Print it up, and we’ll hang it by the sandwich board.”
I was amazed. As far as I can remember, the menu has never changed.
I ran home, worked all day on my sandwich sign, and proudly hung it up. The King of Westport was born!
Lee Shufro (left), with the King of Westport sign.
So if you are in the mood for something a little healthier or different, head over to Gaetano’s, and order my sandwich. J
And be sure to tell them the King sent you.
The King of Westport Sandwich
- Broccoli Rabe
- Sun-dried peppers
- Portabella mushroom
- Grilled artichoke
- Hot peppers
- Pesto
(“06880 covers every inch of Westport — including our delis and restaurants. If stories like this are to your taste, please click here to support our work. Thank you!)
Love Gaetanos!!
nice guy
perhaps a new sandwich ? the nice guy ?
This vegan sandwich made at Gaetano looks good
I love the Sophia Loren and get it every time!!!!
The sandwich sounds delicious! But while it’s clearly vegetarian, it’s NOT vegan. Pesto has parmesan cheese in it
Amazing deli and people. I grew up up in Westport and there has been nothing like it since Art’s Deli owned by Art Falcone which he ran with his family. You just don’t find places like this that often… genuine, personal and attention to sourcing quality ingredients.
I’m in! I don’t eat grains (bread) – but I have found when a sandwich is really good – it’s also really good knocked off the bread. Thank you for putting this one together!